Reason, Debate and a Story

Reason, Debate and a Story

1974 · 120 min · ★ 6.6 · Drama

Four men, each peculiar in his own way, embark on a quest to reason with the estranged wife of the protagonist. This is considered to be Ghatak's autobiographical film.

Directed by Ritwik Ghatak · Written by Ritwik Ghatak

Your Rating

Where to Watch

Streaming

Hoichoi

Cast

Make it a double feature

2h 21m together

Reason, Debate and a Story

Where the River Padma Flows

Both from Ritwik Ghatak.

More from Ritwik GhatakSee all →

Ramkinkar BaijRamkinkar Baij · 1975
Ramkinkar Baij
9.01975
MovieDocumentary
Ramkinkar Baij is an incomplete personality study or documentary on sculptor Ramkinkar Baij created by legendary filmmaker Ritwik Ghatak. He started creating the film in 1975. The film was almost complete but it still remained unfinished for the death of Ritwik Ghatak.
Where the River Padma FlowsWhere the River Padma Flows · 1971
Where the River Padma Flows
9.01971
MovieDocumentaryWar
The film brings to the screen the determination of the common man of Bangladesh to stand up to tyranny and win his priceless liberty back.
FearFear · 1965
Fear
9.01965
MovieScience Fiction
Alarm has been sounded that the hydrogen bomb is about to be dropped. In this atmosphere of panic and fear a cross-section of humanity has been huddled together for safety in an experimental shelter. But even in this crisis the old attitudes and behaviour patterns do not change. FTII Diploma film for acting students of 1964-65 by Ritwik Ghatak.
Heerer PrajapatiHeerer Prajapati · 1968
Heerer Prajapati
8.01968
MovieDrama
the story of a lost butterfly-shaped diamond brooch that belongs to an elderly woman, and its passage through unexpected hands
The UprootedThe Uprooted · 1950
The Uprooted
8.01950
MovieDrama
After Partition, a large group of farmers from East Bengal have to migrate to Calcutta.
The CitizenThe Citizen · 1977
The Citizen
8.01977
MovieDrama
The sole dream of Ramu, eldest son a family of migrants, and Uma to build a happy life together is burdened by a pile of obstacles on their way due to economic upheaval in post-partition Calcutta.
RunawayRunaway · 1958
Runaway
7.41958
MovieDrama
Kanchan, all of eight years old, is always up to pranks and mischief in his village home. He finds his father a cruel demon who keeps his mother oppressed and imprisoned. In his dreams, the big city is El Dorado, until he reaches there.
The Cloud-Capped StarThe Cloud-Capped Star · 1960
The Cloud-Capped Star
7.21960
MovieDrama
A selfless young woman, the daughter of a middle-class refugee family from East Pakistan, sacrifices her own happiness for her unappreciative family.
MusafirMusafir · 1957
Musafir
7.01957
MovieDrama
The stories of three sets of people, linked by their connection to an old suburban house in Calcutta- An orphaned young woman who desperately wants her husband to make up with his estranged parents so that she may belong to a family once more, a wayward young man desperate to find a job to support his aged father and his widowed sister-in-law, and a shadowy neighbourhood ‘madman’
Ustad Alauddin KhanUstad Alauddin Khan · 1963
Ustad Alauddin Khan
7.01963
MovieDocumentaryMusic
Life and disciples of legendary Indian classical musician and teacher, 'Guru' of Pandit Ravishankar, 'Baba' Ustad Alauddin Khan.
Scientists of TomorrowScientists of Tomorrow · 1967
Scientists of Tomorrow
7.01967
Movie
The film explains the details of the research scheme instituted by the Government of India for the benefit of young talented scientists. Under the Scheme, Government encourages students with a scientific bent of mind by awarding scholarships from the B.Sc. to Ph.D. degrees.
MadhumatiMadhumati · 1958
Madhumati
6.91958
MovieDramaRomance
Two men take shelter in a derelict mansion situated in the countryside during a storm. One of the men suddenly becomes aware that he once visited this mansion in a past life; he recounts a story about when he was Anand, a painter, who fell in love with a tribal girl named Madhumati.
AjantrikAjantrik · 1958
Ajantrik
6.91958
MovieDramaComedy
Bimal is a taxi-driver in a small provincial town. He lives alone, his taxi (an old 1920 Chevrolet jalopy which he named Jagaddal) is his only companion and, although very battered, it is the apple of Bimal's eye.
A River Called TitasA River Called Titas · 1973
A River Called Titas
6.71973
MovieDrama
An in-depth look at the lives and struggles of a fishing community living by the River Titas in Bangladesh after the Partition of India in 1947.
The Golden ThreadThe Golden Thread · 1965
The Golden Thread
6.41965
MovieDrama
After an old college friend offers him a job at an iron foundry, the upright and honest Ishwar leaves a shanty town on the outskirts of Calcutta where he lives with a group of refugees from East Bengal. With plans to forge a solid living for himself, sister Sita and Abhiram, an orphaned boy he offers a home to, Ishwar is accused of selling out and deserting his people.
A Soft Note on a Sharp ScaleA Soft Note on a Sharp Scale · 1961
A Soft Note on a Sharp Scale
6.31961
MovieDramaMusic
Set in 1950s Calcutta against the partition of India, the plot follows two rival factions born out of the divided leadership of the radical IPTA theater movement. Amidst their intense creative differences, a romance develops between two uprooted refugees, Bhrigu and Anusuya.

More Like This

Takva: A Man's Fear of GodTakva: A Man's Fear of God · 2006
Takva: A Man's Fear of God
7.22006
MovieDrama
Humble and introvert Muharrem lives in a solitary and meager existence of a prayer and sexual abstinence adhering strictly to the most severe Islamic doctrines.His extraordinary devotion attracts the attention of the leader of a rich and powerful Istanbul religious group and he offers him an administrative post as a rent collector for their numerous properties. Muharrem's new job throws him into the modern outside world he has successfully avoided for so long. He soon witnesses conflict attitude toward alcohol consumption and goodwill.He notices that he himself has become proud, domineering and even dishonest.To make matters worse, Muharrem's inner peace is unnerved by the tormenting image of seductive woman who tempts him in his dreams,both night and day.With the balance of his devotion now upset,his fear of God begins to eat away at his senses.
American GangsterAmerican Gangster · 2007
American Gangster
7.62007
MovieDramaCrime
Loosely based on the criminal career of Frank Lucas, a gangster from La Grange, North Carolina, who smuggled heroin into the United States on American service planes returning from the Vietnam War, before being detained by a task force led by Newark Detective Richie Roberts.
Bicycle ThievesBicycle Thieves · 1948
Bicycle Thieves
8.21948
MovieDrama
Unemployed Antonio is elated when he finally finds work hanging posters around war-torn Rome. However on his first day, his bicycle—essential to his work—gets stolen. His job is doomed unless he can find the thief. With the help of his son, Antonio combs the city, becoming desperate for justice.
Diary of a ChambermaidDiary of a Chambermaid · 1964
Diary of a Chambermaid
7.11964
MovieDramaComedy
Celestine has a new job as a chambermaid for the quirky M. Monteil, his wife and her father. When the father dies, Celestine decides to quit her job and leave, but when a young girl is raped and murdered, Celestine believes that the Monteils' groundskeeper, Joseph, is guilty, and stays on in order to prove it. She uses her sexuality and the promise of marriage to get Joseph to confess -- but things do not go as planned.
The Best of YouthThe Best of Youth · 2003
The Best of Youth
8.02003
MovieDramaHistory
After a fateful encounter in the summer of 1966, the lifepaths of two brothers from a middle-class Roman family diverge, intersecting with some of the most significant events of postwar Italian history in the following decades.
Farewell My ConcubineFarewell My Concubine · 1993
Farewell My Concubine
7.91993
MovieDrama
In an epic tale of theater, gender, love and class, two Beijing opera actors navigate political turmoil as their friendship evolves over decades.
EqualsEquals · 2015
Equals
6.12015
MovieDramaRomance
A futuristic love story set in a world where emotions have been eradicated.
Billy Elliot: The Musical LiveBilly Elliot: The Musical Live · 2014
Billy Elliot: The Musical Live
8.22014
MovieMusicDrama
In County Durham, England, 1984, a talented young dancer, Billy Elliot, stumbles out of the boxing ring and onto the ballet floor. He faces many trials and triumphs as he strives to conquer his family’s set ways, inner conflict, and standing on his toes in a musical that questions masculinity, gender norms and conformity.

Rate this film

Your ratings make Midnight smarter