If I Can't Have You

If I Can't Have You

PG-13 2023 · 88 min · ★ 4.6 · Thriller, TV Movie, Mystery

Disc jockey Michelle Hall attracts the amorous attention of an unknown, demented fan. Meanwhile, back at home, her nosy neighbor seems to watch and know every move she makes.

Directed by David DeCoteau · Written by Adam Rockoff

Your Rating

Where to Watch

Streaming

NetflixAmazon Prime VideoAmazon Prime Video with Ads

Rent or Buy

Amazon Video

Cast

Make it a double feature

2h 53m together

If I Can't Have You

The Wrong Baby Daddy

Both from David DeCoteau.

More from David DeCoteauSee all →

The Wrong Baby DaddyThe Wrong Baby Daddy · 2026
The Wrong Baby Daddy
10.02026
MovieDramaThriller
Lila’s life finally feels complete when she starts a dream job with her close friend Robin, falls into a promising romance with Mark, and discovers she’s pregnant. But everything shifts when Julia, Mark’s ex-wife, reappears the moment she learns about the baby. At first, Julia’s involvement seems harmless, even polite, until she begins showing up uninvited, inserting herself into every corner of Lila’s new life. As Julia’s presence grows more intrusive and her intentions more unsettling, Lila realizes she may be fighting to protect far more than just her future. Soon, what began as a perfect new chapter becomes a tense battle of boundaries, obsession, and survival.
Keeping Up with the JonesesKeeping Up with the Joneses · 2021
Keeping Up with the Joneses
8.82021
SeriesDrama
After the death of patriarch Theodore Jones, his second wife Robin and Theodore's daughters work to protect their family and business after they are threatened.
The Disaster ArtistThe Disaster Artist · 2017
The Disaster Artist
7.12017
MovieComedyDrama
An aspiring actor in Hollywood meets an enigmatic stranger by the name of Tommy Wiseau, the meeting leads the actor down a path nobody could have predicted; creating the worst movie ever made.
The Wrong StepmotherThe Wrong Stepmother · 2019
The Wrong Stepmother
6.82019
MovieTV MovieThriller
Michael, who lost his wife a few years back, has been use to being a single dad to his two daughters until his new girlfriend Maddie comes along.
Tuff TurfTuff Turf · 1985
Tuff Turf
6.01985
MovieDramaAction
The new guy in a Los Angeles high school, Morgan, does some singing and fights hotshot Nick over disco dancer Frankie.
The Wrong Housemaid
NEW
The Wrong Housemaid · 2026
The Wrong Housemaid
6.02026
MovieThriller
After vanishing from her violent husband's grasp ten years ago, Mona thought she had finally secured a peaceful new life for herself and her teenage daughter, Denise, behind carefully crafted new identities. But their fragile safety shatters when a seemingly harmless housemaid enters their home and begins manipulating their lives with chilling precision.
Puppet Master IIPuppet Master II · 1990
Puppet Master II
6.01990
MovieHorror
A new team of paranormal researchers has come to the hotel to investigate its murder-soaked past; the puppets -- led by a new member, Torch -- shed some light on the matter, as they tunnel, burn, strangle and hook to survive.
As Luck Would Have ItAs Luck Would Have It · 2023
As Luck Would Have It
5.72023
SeriesMysteryDrama
Recently retired criminology professor turned amateur sleuth Gabbi Luck uses her classroom smarts, charm and tenacity to get to the bottom of every crime she encounters. She balances each case with daughter Lisa who is a detective and partner Rick. Gabbi is sometimes assisted by police Captain Taylor, Barbara who works at the station, husband Michael and police psychologist, Dr. Nolan.
Trancers IITrancers II · 1991
Trancers II
5.61991
MovieActionScience Fiction
Once again someone from the future has come back to create an army of Trancers, human zombies who do what they're told without question or pause. Now officer Jack Deth, a cop from the future stranded in the past, must once again go forth to stop them. This sci-fi action sequel chronicles his courageous actions as he struggles to save the future. His difficulties are compounded when his boss sends his first wife back from the future to help Deth who has unfortunately, married a 20th-century girl.
The Wrong TeacherThe Wrong Teacher · 2018
The Wrong Teacher
5.62018
MovieDramaTV Movie
Successful teacher and author Charlotte Hansen has a passionate, one-night stand with a younger man, Chris. She later finds out that he is 18 years old and a student at her high school. Now, Chris will stop at nothing to have her for himself.
Skinned AliveSkinned Alive · 1990
Skinned Alive
5.11990
MovieComedyHorror
Crawldaddy and her two kids are travelling across the country on the search for victims. The dysfunctional family has the disturbing habit of skinning people alive before killing them. When their van breaks down, they are put up by a friendly couple.
Steel and LaceSteel and Lace · 1991
Steel and Lace
5.01991
MovieActionHorror
After her attackers go free, Gaily Morton, the victim of a vicious assault, commits suicide. Her vengeful brother, brilliant robotics engineer and scientist, Dr. Albert Morton, decides to use his skills to enact vengeance, transplanting his sister's brain into a humanoid cyborg with bone-crushing strength and an array of built-in torture devices...
Sorority Babes in the Slimeball Bowl-O-RamaSorority Babes in the Slimeball Bowl-O-Rama · 1988
Sorority Babes in the Slimeball Bowl-O-Rama
4.81988
MovieComedyHorror
Out to steal a trophy from a local bowling alley, a group of college students accidentally unleash the imp -- a sadistic little spirit that creates demons and loves sexy women.
WitchouseWitchouse · 1999
Witchouse
4.81999
MovieHorror
On Mayday 1998 in the town of Dunwich, Massachusetts, Elizabeth gathers together a group of specially selected friends for a rather odd party. It turns out that she is the descendent of a malevolent witch named Lilith who was burned at the stake precisely three hundred years ago. Now Elizabeth hopes to resurrect her dreadful ancestor and has a specific (and murderous) need for the guests she has chosen
Ghoul SchoolGhoul School · 1990
Ghoul School
4.71990
MovieHorror
Two sniveling high school dropouts plot to rob the school janitor and accidentally release toxic chemicals into the school's water supply. The swimming team are the first ones to turn into green-faced flesh-eating zombies, and they promptly go after the rest of the present school populace: two horror movie nerds, the members of a metal band and the world's worst basketball team.
Charles Band's Puppet Master: Axis of EvilCharles Band's Puppet Master: Axis of Evil · 2010
Charles Band's Puppet Master: Axis of Evil
4.62010
MovieHorrorWar
Following the murder of Andre Toulon by Nazi assassins during the height of World War II, a young Danny Coogan finds his crate of mysterious puppets, and discovers their plan to attack a secret American manufacturing plant.

More Like This

Couldn't load this row right now.

More on NetflixSee all →

Facing El Chapo
NEW
Facing El Chapo · 2026
Facing El Chapo
8.82026
MovieCrimeAction
Two Mexican officers must survive the final hours of their shift after crossing a ruthless cartel boss.
The Whisper Man
NEW
The Whisper Man · 2026
The Whisper Man
6.82026
MovieCrimeDrama
When his young son vanishes, a widower enlists help from his estranged father, a retired detective who put away the serial killer now linked to the case.
Spider-Man: No Way HomeSpider-Man: No Way Home · 2021
Spider-Man: No Way Home
7.92021
MovieActionAdventure
Peter Parker is unmasked and no longer able to separate his normal life from the high-stakes of being a super-hero. When he asks for help from Doctor Strange the stakes become even more dangerous, forcing him to discover what it truly means to be Spider-Man.
Gandhari
NEW
Gandhari · 2026
Gandhari
4.62026
MovieActionDrama
When a mother loses her eyesight and her daughter in a kidnapping, she takes matters into her own hands to hunt down those responsible.
The Secret Woman
NEW
The Secret Woman · 2026
The Secret Woman
6.42026
MovieDramaThriller
After discovering she has a family and a shipping empire, a woman with amnesia returns to a wealthy and seemingly perfect past to uncover why she left.
Spider-ManSpider-Man · 2002
Spider-Man
7.42002
MovieActionScience Fiction
After being bitten by a genetically altered spider at Oscorp, nerdy but endearing high school student Peter Parker is endowed with amazing powers to become the superhero known as Spider-Man.
The Last HouseThe Last House · 2026
The Last House
6.92026
MovieHorrorScience Fiction
A family suddenly sealed inside their home must work together to survive against dwindling resources and the ominous threat keeping them trapped.
Spider-Man: HomecomingSpider-Man: Homecoming · 2017
Spider-Man: Homecoming
7.32017
MovieActionAdventure
Following the events of Captain America: Civil War, Peter Parker, with the help of his mentor Tony Stark, tries to balance his life as an ordinary high school student in Queens, New York City, with fighting crime as his superhero alter ego Spider-Man as a new threat, the Vulture, emerges.
Elize: Shadows of a WomanElize: Shadows of a Woman · 2026
Elize: Shadows of a Woman
7.52026
MovieThrillerCrime
In this retelling of a real case, a former escort discovers her wealthy husband's infidelity and struggles to cope as betrayal poisons their marriage.
Fight ClubFight Club · 1999
Fight Club
8.41999
MovieDramaThriller
A ticking-time-bomb insomniac and a slippery soap salesman channel primal male aggression into a shocking new form of therapy. Their concept catches on, with underground "fight clubs" forming in every town, until an eccentric gets in the way and ignites an out-of-control spiral toward oblivion.
Spider-Man 3Spider-Man 3 · 2007
Spider-Man 3
6.52007
MovieActionAdventure
The seemingly invincible Spider-Man goes up against an all-new crop of villains—including the shape-shifting Sandman. While Spider-Man’s superpowers are altered by an alien organism, his alter ego, Peter Parker, deals with nemesis Eddie Brock and also gets caught up in a love triangle.
SwappedSwapped · 2026
Swapped
8.92026
MovieAdventureAnimation
A small woodland creature and a majestic bird, two natural sworn enemies of the Valley, magically trade places and set off on an adventure of a lifetime to switch back. Their journey soon uncovers a greater threat—one that could endanger not only their species, but the entire valley they call home.
The Wild RobotThe Wild Robot · 2024
The Wild Robot
8.32024
MovieFamilyAnimation
After a shipwreck, an intelligent robot called Roz is stranded on an uninhabited island. To survive the harsh environment, Roz bonds with the island's animals and cares for an orphaned baby goose.
DesireDesire · 2026
Desire
6.72026
MovieMysteryDrama
Lucero’s life appears immaculate: a wealthy household, a devoted husband, and two children who embody the promise of a perfect family. Yet beneath this surface simmers a quiet dissatisfaction. When Matías, a young swimming coach hired by her husband, enters their lives, Lucero finds herself pulled into a risky and consuming relationship. As secrecy, desire, and jealousy tighten their grip, the boundaries within the family begin to collapse, placing mother and daughter in a dangerous emotional triangle that threatens to shatter everything Lucero has built.
War MachineWar Machine · 2026
War Machine
7.52026
MovieActionScience Fiction
On one last grueling mission during Army Ranger training, a combat engineer must lead his unit in a fight against a giant otherworldly killing machine.
GOATGOAT · 2026
GOAT
8.12026
MovieAnimationComedy
A small goat with big dreams gets a once-in-a-lifetime shot to join the pros and play roarball, a high-intensity, co-ed, full-contact sport dominated by the fastest, fiercest animals in the world.
Dhamaal 4Dhamaal 4 · 2026
Dhamaal 4
3.32026
MovieComedy
The Dhamaal boys are back for another treasure hunt, facing hilarious challenges in their quest for the Treasure of Life.
The TerminatorThe Terminator · 1984
The Terminator
7.71984
MovieActionThriller
In the post-apocalyptic future, reigning tyrannical supercomputers teleport a cyborg assassin known as the "Terminator" back to 1984 to kill Sarah Connor, whose unborn son is destined to lead insurgents against 21st century mechanical hegemony. Meanwhile, the human-resistance movement dispatches a lone warrior to safeguard Sarah. Can he stop the virtually indestructible killing machine?
Spirited AwaySpirited Away · 2001
Spirited Away
8.52001
MovieAnimationFamily
A young girl, Chihiro, becomes trapped in a strange new world of spirits. When her parents undergo a mysterious transformation, she must call upon the courage she never knew she had to free her family.
KPop Demon HuntersKPop Demon Hunters · 2025
KPop Demon Hunters
8.02025
MovieFantasyMusic
When K-pop superstars Rumi, Mira and Zoey aren't selling out stadiums, they're using their secret powers to protect their fans from supernatural threats.

Rate this film

Your ratings make Midnight smarter